sfsignal


News Feeds
Add to Google Entries
Add to Google Commments

Subscribe with FeedBurner
Search


« How High-Definition Is Bad News for SF Flicks | Home | SF Tidbits for 11/16/06 »
« How High-Definition Is Bad News for SF Flicks | Home | SF Tidbits for 11/16/06 »
REVIEW: Wizard By Trade by Jim Butcher (SFBC Omnibus Collection)


MY RATING:
BRIEF SYNOPSIS: The continuing adventures of Chicago's only openly practicing wizard P.I.
PROS: Non-stop action, smooth prose, interesting characters, unique setting, a page-turner.
CONS: Quite often Harry extricates himself from dire situations via the plot and not his own initiative, not much character development, more convoluted plots.
BOTTOM LINE: A very entertaining and enjoyable read. This combination of fantasy/supernatural and P.I. genres works very well. A must read for fantasy fans.

MY REVIEW:
Wizard By Trade is the second Science Fiction Book Club omnibus volume covering the further adventures of Harry Dresden. This volume includes Summer Knight and Death Masks.


Everything I said about Wizard For Hire still applies to Wizard By Trade. Harry is a sympathetic character, even if he has a bit of a hero complex, and he has a knack for taking enormous amounts of physical damage and still comes out kicking. He's also extremely clever and lucky, which helps him outwit those arrayed against him. I still feel Harry is an interesting character, I just think that, after all he's been through, he might change somewhat as a person, but he's still basically the same person as in the first story.

One other point, the plots in the two stories presented here are a bit more complex and convoluted than in the previous stories which made it a bit more work to figure out what, exactly, was going on. But that's really just a small nit in an otherwise action-packed, page turning series. I think anyone who likes fantasy will like this volume of Harry Dresden stories.

Share: | Posted by JP on Wednesday November 15, 2006 - 3:35 PM | Category: Book Review | © 2006 SF Signal



Comments

Just wanted to tell you that I visited sfsignal every day and enjoy your news/reviews/commentary immensely. Keep up the good work!

Posted by Bob on Wednesday November 15, 2006 at 5:29 PM

Have this book on order.. can't wait to read.

Posted by SciFiChick on Thursday November 16, 2006 at 8:44 AM

How does it compare to Cook's fantasy PI series (if you have read them)?

Posted by Fred Kiesche on Thursday November 16, 2006 at 10:16 AM

I haven't read anything by Cook, nor do I cook at home, so I can't compare them.

:D

Posted by jp on Thursday November 16, 2006 at 2:09 PM



Post a Comment









Remember personal info?



[Use a smiley: Add this smiley Add this smiley Add this smiley Add this smiley Add this smiley Add this smiley Add this smiley Add this smiley Add this smiley Add this smiley Add this smiley Add this smiley Add this smiley Add this smiley ]
[Use shortcuts: URL, BOLD or ITALICIZE ]