Taking author John Scalzi up on his request to post about what I consider to be a most overrated work, I submit the movie E.T. the Extra-Terrestrial. Now I know many people consider this a great film and heartwarming and it certainly was popular. But I’ve never liked it. Most importantly, I thought it was a bad piece of science fiction with little even slightly plausible. The McGuyver-style phone home machine just capped it off for me as terrible. I saw it described as a dog movie – that is boy meets dog, boy names dog, boy grows up, etc. – and to a large part that’s true. The alien doesn’t have to be alien at all – it was developed based on Spielberg’s childhood imaginary friend and it shows. The kids end up proving to be wiser than parents, and the dog runs away, er – E.T. goes home. Of course, my family loves the movie and I am ridiculed for my dislike.
As for the extra credit assignment (was there ever an effort that initially I disliked but then thought better of) I submit Fargo. I didn’t care for it at all the first time I saw it in the theatre, but have since come to think of it as quirky and funny. I figure it was my state of mind on the day in question.
And as a side note, I too read Dune when I was about 12 and did not like it at all. I’ve often thought about rereading as an adult to see what I missed. Scalzi’s comments encourage me to do so.