News Ticker

EW Reviews SF

Noah Robischon of Entertainment Weekly, the rag mag everyone turns to for sf reviews, has published their brief monthly roundup of recent sf books. To wit:

  • WEAPONS OF CHOICE by John Birmingham
    • Grade: A
    • Lowdown: Birmingham’s enthralling battleground mixes provocative historical fiction and socially conscious futurism.
  • IRON SUNRISE by Charles Stross
    • Grade: B+
    • Lowdown: Sunrise, while unnecessarily complex in spots, is a Hollywood thriller with a cyberpunk heart.
  • RADIANT by James Alan Gardner
    • Grade: B-
    • Lowdown: The tenacious Explorers propel the Trek-like saga forward, though gardner’s emotionless prose would make a poet out of Spock.
  • IRON COUNCIL by China Miéville;
    • Grade: C+
    • Lowdown: Miéville’s phantasmagoric story is eclipsed by a glut of flawed heroes and an invented vernacular that impedes its own progress.
About John DeNardo (13012 Articles)
John DeNardo is the Managing Editor at SF Signal and a columnist at Kirkus Reviews. He also likes bagels. So there.

2 Comments on EW Reviews SF

  1. Stross: Overly complex? Gee, I guess so for somebody who probably restricts his reading to his own magazine and copies of “Variety”, plus summaries of screen treatments.


  2. Heh, I was thinking the same thing. Which leads me to believe the Weapons of Choice isn’t all that. Although I’ve seen a lot of mixed reviews of Iron Council, I’ll probably still pick it up and read it.

Comments are closed.

%d bloggers like this: