News Ticker

REVIEW: Midnighters #1 – The Secret Hour by Scott Westerfeld

REVIEW SUMMARY: Another fun book from Scott Westerfeld.


BRIEF SYNOPSIS: A group of kids who possess supernatural abilities during the midnight hour fight off the sinister darklings.


PROS: Fast-paced and interesting; cool depiction of the dark hour.

CONS: I would have liked to see more interplay between the characters when the Midnighters used their powers. The explanation of frozen time doesn’t quite hold up under any reasonable amount of scrutiny.

BOTTOM LINE: A fun read for kids and adults.

Seeing as how I read Scott Westerfeld’s Succession books and liked them very much, I wanted to read some more of his fiction. Since the other adult titles of his I own, Polymorph and Fine Prey, are buried away in some boxes in a remote and undisclosed location, scheduled to be unearthed around 2047, I thought I would try one of his young adult titles which was more readily at hand. His Midnighters series fit the bill quite nicely.

Book #1, titled The Secret Hour introduces the concept of the series: the day really has 25 hours and at midnight, time freezes for everyone except for a small group of young people who call themselves Midnighters. Each Midnighter has a special supernatural power during the dark hour. The bad news is that this is also the time when their hometown of Bixby, Oklahoma is populated by dark, sinister, shape-shifting creatures called the darklings. Jessica Day, a new Bixby resident, has yet to learn the town’s secret, but she will. Jessica is also a Midnighter with powers that are apparently so fierce, the darklings decide to emerge from the outer badlands and go after her.

Like his Succession series, Westerfeld has written a quick-moving story that keeps interest levels high. Fifteen-year-old Jessica, having just moved from Chicago to the small town of Bixby, has much to deal with. At first she thinks she is dreaming when a midnight rainstorm stops, water droplets hanging in mid-air, while the rest of the world emits a blue glow. Eventually she realizes she is not dreaming when she hooks up with a band of other high schoolers who share her ability to remain awake during the extra midnight hour.

Each of the Midnighters has a special power during the dark hour. Desdemona (Dess) is a polymath. Her expertise with numbers is a skill she uses to good effect when she charges weapons to fight off the darklings. Melissa is a psychic who can read the thoughts of everyone in Bixby and project her own. Her ability is somewhat of a handicap so she blocks the overwhelming “noise” of other people’s thoughts by listening to music headphones. Sadly for her, the dark hour is her only respite. Jonathan can defy gravity, hopping long distances giving him a pseudo-flying ability. Rex is a master of Midnighter lore, with the ability to see the signs of the phenomenon. Jessica’s, being new to the dark hour, has a power that is something of mystery and not revealed until the end of the book. Taken together, the Midnighters make a formidable team, but I would have liked to see more interplay between the characters when they used their powers.

The best parts of the book were when Westerfeld describes what life is like in the dark hour. For example, a motionless car in the street can become a sudden danger if you’re standing in front of it at 1:00 AM; Jessica runs her hand through some “frozen” rain and it wets her fingers; Non-Midnighters appear pale when the clock strikes twelve. The only thing that didn’t make too much sense is the exact nature and details of the frozen time with regards to time zones. When time is frozen in Bixby, the rest of the world is still in motion, right? How does that work? I guess the mention of collapsed time (12:00 AM for the Midnighters, the other 24 hours for the darklings) is supposed to explain it, but I would have like a more concrete explanation. Or maybe I’m being too nitpicky.

In recent discussions, it was mentioned that fiction aimed at (or perhaps “marketed to” is a better phrase) kids comes in two flavors: “children’s” fiction and “young adult”. The former is the more traditional definition where a book does not contain mature themes. The latter books contain mature themes like sex, violence, etc. I would classify The Secret Hour as a children’s book. The most mature thing within it is a budding romance and kiss between Jessica and someone with whom she can finally relate in her strange new environment. Parents of younger readers may also want to know that there is much sneaking about under the adults’ noses at midnight. Otherwise, it’s a normal portrayal of a kid’s life in a new town, a new school, and a bratty kid sister. Oh, and supernatural powers.

Overall, Midnighters #1 – The Secret Hour is a fun read for kids and adults.

About John DeNardo (13013 Articles)
John DeNardo is the Managing Editor at SF Signal and a columnist at Kirkus Reviews. He also likes bagels. So there.

18 Comments on REVIEW: Midnighters #1 – The Secret Hour by Scott Westerfeld

  1. I loved the series. I was on a fansite of Charmed and had heard that one of the producers might make a television series out of the Midnighter trilogy, so I thought I’d check it out. Once I picked up the books, I couldn’t put any of them down. The only thing that I didn’t like was that it was too vague on the powers of the Midnighters. It said that there were a lot more powers than they knew about. Also, I must admit that the ending of the series made me cry.

  2. I just got finished reading Midnighters: The Secret Hour. I loved it. I was wondering how many seguels there are, I heard there were three.(counting The Secret Hour) I would really like to know, so I could read all of them. Thanks!-Maegan

  3. Maegen,

    There are three books in the Midnighters sequence: The Secret Hour, Touching Darkness and Blue Noon.

    Check out Scott Westerfeld’s website for more Midnighters info.

  4. :Domg i just copied u guys summary so i can use it on my book report but it is such a wonderful book how many series are there by the way???????????

  5. New slogan: “SF Signal. Helping kids cheat at their homework since 2003.” (H)

  6. Chelsey // May 13, 2008 at 6:03 pm //

    I just finished the third one and it was awesome the ending was so… i dont know different and unexpected it took a turn i didnt see coming. it was so sad i started crying.

  7. OMG i luvd the series, but the end made me cry *sob*

  8. Sacred Nym // August 26, 2008 at 5:14 pm //

    This seems strikingly similar to the PS2 game Persona 3

  9. Made.In.Heaven // August 27, 2008 at 4:54 am //

    It can’t be… This book is waaaaaay too similar to Persona 3! But it’s released in 2004, and P3 was probably being developed around this time so this might just be a coincidence.

  10. Ive played Persona 3,I think I will check this book out!

  11. audrey yocom // November 7, 2008 at 10:06 am //

    i loved your books they are so awesome. i hope that you will make more in the midnighters series.

  12. Anonymous // January 21, 2009 at 8:56 am //

    hahahahaha yall folks trip me out!!!! im about to copy these summaries thanks

  13. Good idea.  Because teachers know nothing about the Internet.

  14. Joanne Bertrand // April 17, 2009 at 5:07 am //

    Hi John,

    I am a school principal. A Grade 6 teacher of ours is reading The Secret Hour to her students. One family, Christian, is objecting to it but I really can’t find fault in it, especially after your review.

    John, could you please give me your qualifications? I have a meeting with this mom at 10 a.m. today, April 17.



  15. I’m just a reader and a parent.

  16. in the third pharaghraph you said her name is jennifer… i thought it was jessica.. right?

  17. Wow — good catch.  Where were you three-and-a-half years ago? 🙂

  18. i wish they explored more of the powers they could have or learned new ones :/ wish she’d write more about midnighters ^^

Comments are closed.

%d bloggers like this: