News Ticker

[GUEST POST] Michaele Jordan on Whether or Not To Nominate (Where is that Pesky Line?)

Michaele Jordan‘s novel, Blade Light, is a charming traditional fantasy that was serialized in Jim Baen’s Universe and is now available as an ebook at Amazon or at iBooks. Her newest novel, Mirror Maze, is available now.

To Nominate or Not To Nominate (or, Where is that Pesky Line?)

The other day we were hanging out with some friends, and my husband (who-bless his heart-is insanely proud of me) boasted to the gang that since I was a member of SFWA now, I was eligible to nominate for the Nebulas.

“Ooh, that’s cool,” gushed one of my friends who (like me) is a great admirer of Neal Stephenson. “Are you going to nominate Reamde?”

“Don’t be silly,” snorted another. “She can’t nominate Reamde; it’s not SF.”

A minor argument ensued. No hard feelings resulted, but neither was the disagreement resolved. In fact, they are probably still at the coffee shop, arguing. (My husband and I went home).

Is Reamde SF?

While taking care to include no spoilers, I can tell you that much of the story focuses on a fictional on-line role playing game. The game is, as far as I can tell, slightly in advance of anything that currently exists (not because real world money changes hands through this game, since that is already possible) but other than that it is set in the real world. So most would probably argue that Reamde is not SF. It is a high-tech thriller. Certainly, it is not included in the SFWA recommended-reading-for-nebula-nomination list.

If high-tech thrillers qualified as SF, most James Bond movies would be SF. And they’re not. Are they? Perhaps they do not qualify because they are not perceived as being in advance of modern technology, especially with allowances made for secret research. But very few of us are so scientifically literate that we could invariably distinguish between state of the art, and very near future technology. And what if the science is, or turns out, to be wrong?

But if slight technical advances are not sufficient to qualify a work as SF, then just how far out in the future or far away from earth does the work have to go before it counts as SF? Surprise! That’s a rhetorical question. I don’t know. And I’m not going to speculate. I only asked to set up the next question: why do we care? Reamde is an excellent book. Nominations aside, that should be enough

And yet, somehow, it isn’t. My friend suggested I nominate it because they loved the book and wanted it included in the canon. One reviewer plaintively remarked that they wished Stephenson would go back to writing SF. Many fans view reading books that are not SF/F as disloyal. There are blogs that cruise the internet in search of slights against SF and then launch spectacular tantrums whenever they think they have found one. Outsiders don’t respect SF, I am assured. We are treated as inferior.

Really? Where? I have an extensive mundane life. I attend a synagogue where I am not looked down on for writing SF/F; I am looked down on for writing fiction. If I wanted respect, I should have become a rabbi. My Christian mother-in-law agrees in spirit; she reads nothing but biographies of brave women who found strength in their faith. I do business daily with people who are only borderline literate and have never read any book voluntarily.

I do know several serious literary snobs. They are all fans. I count on them to alert me to SF/F outside the normal channels. Yet every month there is another argument on Facebook about those mean literary types looking down on us. And if we have enemies, we must defend our borders.

We live in a very genre conscious culture. Everything has to have a label, a quick, easy marketing ID. I am not criticizing. We need labels because we live in a morass of information, which cannot be used, or even comfortably tolerated, without organization. But we do not like being labeled. Firstly, we always worry (rightly or wrongly) that the label is pejorative in the mouth of an outsider. Secondly, we invariably find the label too restrictive.

So we jump the boundaries. In publishing, it is now called genre crossing. Having reduced our literary world to vampire novels, romances, westerns and noir, we find that we cannot live within such narrow definitions, and we rebel with vampire westerns and noir romances. Urban fantasy started out as a cross genre of mainstream and fantasy (and romance). So can we say the SF/F boundary is sacred? Wherever it is?

I should be triumphantly assembling my conclusion now. But I am stumped. Instead I invite you, the readers of SF Signal-yourselves a major voice of fandom-to tell me: do we have boundaries? And if so, what are they?

Meanwhile, maybe I will nominate Reamde. Just to mess with you.

8 Comments on [GUEST POST] Michaele Jordan on Whether or Not To Nominate (Where is that Pesky Line?)

  1. Is a novel that a SF writer does a SF novel, even if the elements are marginal.

    Greg Bear’s Quantico novels also fell into this space as Reamde.

  2. The SFWA recommended reading list isn’t an official list of all the eligible things. It’s a place where members recommend things to each other. You could post the book there right now, should you want to. It wouldn’t mean you can say, “SFWA says it’s science fiction, because it’s on the recommended reading list.” Anymore than you can say it’s not science fiction because it’s not on the list.

  3. #correction ‘Whether of Not’ = ‘Whether or Not’ in title

  4. Thanks, Tam. Looks like I picked the wrong week to stop sniffing glue.

  5. I thought the Nebula wasn’t limited to SF?

  6. You are quite right. Absence from the list does not really indicate that the book isn’t SF, just that no one so far has included it in their nominations. But in view of Stephenson’s popularity, and as late as it is in the nomination process, I thought it was suggestive that no one had nominated it.

  7. Lise, I never thought to ask whether the nominations had to be SF/F. But the nominators have to be members of SFWA, so I assumed (yes, I know, assumptions are evil) that they would be doing so within their own field.

Comments are closed.

%d bloggers like this: